binary options methods machine signals 2015
binary options kelly formula strategy 60
redwood binary option suffix mt4 indicator
greg davis binary options bully review chart software
binary option trading minimum deposit 100 market
binary options support and resistance strategy account
binary options easy withdrawal broker in us
my binary options trading video mrlivetrade
end of day binary options signals 50 deposit
binary options affiliate network 60 seconds
tools to trade binary options
binary options brokers for us citizens review option japan
pros and cons of binary options broker australia
good price binary options website script coupon codes sale
top 3 binary options is it worth
binary option 24h system lowyat
understanding cysec regulated binary options brokers
synthetic best times to trade binary option
deposit best usa binary option 2015
5 minute earn from binary options scam brokers
are binary option any good no minimum deposit
twelve suggestions for picking binary options brokers
binary options market times
forex how to win in binary options trader 2015
e t binary options ltd bonuses
binary option neteller system 01
deposit difference between binary option and digital options 2015
fsa binary options brokers trading questions
buy binary options tradinglegalusreviews shopping
0 out of 5 based on 1 ratings for 24option binary trading 1
content binary options ebook 32 websites
can you win on binary option system 76
platform binary options demo trading page
binary option pricing and greeks strategies m
binary options 5 bonus 300
reliable and authentic 5 minutes binary options strategy
how to make money from binary option bot 2 0
binary options platform promoters
forex vs best moving averages for binary options
pricing of boss indicator binary options
is binary options trading united states real
anti martingale binary options usa
5 minute binary options di indonesia
forbes and binary options queen software review
4xp dual binary options demo
24 bulls us binary options brokers
metatrader indicator for binary option holy grail
best us binary options 90 payout
binary options auto bot game
binary option trading signals 2015 collar
binary options coaching striker 9
no deposit binary options winning martingale 2015
free binary option trading demo accounts signal
binary options brokers registered with cftc legal in uk
binary option pros and cons help
no scam binary options cftc
binary options trading workshop bullet ex4
ig group binary options trading broker
binary options education center
4xp binary options signal service providers demo
binary option legal or forex
non regulated binary options brokers interactive
forex trading and binary option regulations
the right approach to trade binary options
binary options account manager uk law
binary option system evaluation
rich binary option traders investing
60s binary option system 50 minimum deposit
tricks of binary options signals scam review
binary option methodist college tutorial
training on bowf binary options
name possibility method of binary options trading
binary option m5 charts tricks
how to make money using binary options email
binary option free start system x3650
binary option system help
example of binary options money saving expert
double trading binary option close to expiry
mt4 for binary options strategies health insurance tanzania
itm xgen alpari binary options term swing indicator
news analysis for binary options trading how to trade news
knock 60 second profits binary option system
best binary option forum for beginners methods0809
cboe binary options volatility bvz
my binary options system 81 account
binary options trading bot buddy 2 0 ex4
binary options located in usa 24 hours
binary options regulated by cftc real
binary options chart trend analys
trade binary option on mt4 pricing model
binary option methods 0f suturing legit
trade binary options system 6 kitchens
binary option broker in us
how to make profit with binary options good or bad
dtails forex robot opzioni binarie binary options bbtrigger bonus
24 no deposit binary options get 100 for free scam
binary option trading group halal
get this binary options software
how to win in binary options 80 s night white label
binary options daily the best way to trade properly
binary options in singapore 300
24 hour binary options does it work
cysec best settings for binary options robot
volatility binary option
profit 60 sec binary options strategy
best online broker for binary option us
binary options fake itm
3 how to win in binary options 911 trading strategies for beginners
bob101 how to trade binary options
e trade binary options signals coupon codes
indicator 60 seconds binary option software 2015
60 second binary options systems pimp
binary option trick
binary options trading tutorial pdf robot ex4
how to value a binary option coaching
best regulated binary options brokers terminology
digital vs binary option methods nakamura
binary option bullet ex4 replication
binary options earnings strategy 2015
virtual binary options trading
u s binary options popularity chart
is binary options system integrator legal in australia
24 binary options system analyst review
four things that all binary options traders must have
best binary options brokers australia international
eforex magazine fx mythbusters binary options friend or foe to forex brokers
binary options education gives you the best way to trade
binary options monthly performance brokers japan
60s best strategy for 60 second binary option system
binary option comparison no deposit 2015
what strategies will help read a chart for binary options buddy 3 0
binary option demos profit
binary option 101 course review delta
what is a binary option broker 5
gamma of a simple binary option system
hero binary options system trends
binary options strategy 90
do how to well with binary options work
internet top binary options traders
easy profit binary option trading demo account
price of binary options safe
binary option game strategies 0
binary options trader insight december 3rd 2015
zulutrade binary options trading environment
are binary option legal in india crash
index binary options system banker 11 online
binary option free bonus language
binary options cyprus india
how to profit from 60 second binary options compounding
10 one touch binary option pricing
looking for us binary options brokers by rome barassamian
safest binary options chart reading
binary option trading free bonus system 80
binary options prediction indicator oanda
hourly binary options call or put
can i really make money trading binary options xp
binary option by abe cofnas multiplier
binary option millionaires review 24h
24option offers new binary options signals
binary option robot torrent yahoo
trade forex binary options no deposit bonus uk
option binary options robot youtube
binary options 3 llc tricks
us binary option 24 7 broker
hotforex value chart binary options
binary option forex signal
binary options queen software 101 home study course
binary option system indicator 636
24 hr best binary options signals forum
binary option 260 to 22134 in 4 days live account contracts
is binary options trading profitable broker uk
ioption shocks the binary options market and shuts down
best us binary options brokers journey
dealing with binary options jobs cyprus
24 binary options sales scam
xp market tick charts and binary options
is binary option legal in us
how to win in binary options trading syst
binary options are they real broker scams
binary options system mechanic 6 programs
buy xpmarketbinary options coupon codes shopping
binary option in trading world
exchange traded binary options brokers
binary options broker in usa picks
cherry trade binary options review signals 90
binary options trading signals free download 90
binary option min deposit expert
redwood binary options review bosses or just bums
SECONDDRAFT.ORG
Home VEA Section France2 Steps in the Pallywood Doodoo… and what a revealing whopper!

France2 Steps in the Pallywood Doodoo…
and what a revealing whopper!

A recent incident, well covered in both the blogosphere and (some) of the MSM, casts a brilliant light on some of the darker alleys of the media theater of war, particularly on the inner workings of Pallywood.

France2’s combination of “the tailor” Talal abu Rahme and his boss, “the chamberlain” Charles Enderlin, producing the Pallywood magnum opus al Durah, first revealed the workings of this disturbing symbiosis of Palestinian and Western media to me in October 2003.

Not content with his work, Enderlin, in one of those fits of arrogance that often befall those who fool too many people too often, got France2 to sue Philippe Karsenty for saying France2 had presented the staged Al Durah Hoax as real news. In the appeals case, the court demanded that Enderlin show the (Pallywood) footage (which he cut), and then presented the court with a video that used Pallywood footage to try and convince the court they didn’t use staged footage.

They deservedly lost in court.

Now we see them in a particularly egregious error that anyone who had been paying the slightest attention to what the issues involved in Palestinian footage would have caught:

I. The incident: On September 23, 2005, at a celebration of the “victory” of having driven the Israelis from Gaza after the “Disengagement,” a victory float of Hamas “activists” and their arsenal exploded, killing more than a dozen Palestinian civilians including several children drawn by the sight of the weaponry. Hamas tried, in true Pallywood style, to blame Israel, but with a less than united front between Hamas and Fatah, the real story leaked so badly the press did not snatch at the proferred bait. Of course, once the Israelis were no longer to blame, the story — Palestinian militants kill Palestinian civilians — had no legs. For the MSM, it died there.

II. The resurrection of the mutilated flesh: On January 1, 2009, Mounir1426 put up one of his first videos at LiveLink entitled, ISRAEL CARNAGE CIVILIANS CHILDREN GAZA. The explanation offered: Israel just bombed a large civilian street market in Gaza. His logo reads: FOR GAZA.

 

\



Ca fait mal au coeur gaza palastin 01/01/2009 choc
Uploaded by sahsah83

III. Viral Spread: The video spread rapidly particularly in Muslim and radical anti-Zionist circles, with half a million hits in some cases. Including a French site. [Documentation of its viral spread welcome here.]

IV. The immediate response of the critical blogosphere nails the video as incorrect. Already Sunday, January 4, Little Green Footballs summarized the discussion to that point. Even the poster of the video admitted error (although he refused to take down the libelous running header for fear of “losing the conversational thread that would ensue with changing it).

V. France2 runs with it: On the afternoon, Monday, January 5, 2009 France2 ran the following program in which they both reported Palestinian claims of a bomb hitting a house and killing a family of five, and then this report of a Gaza market place:

 



Israel Gaza point 13h00 sur F2 et Images de 2005
Uploaded by ReadyHdFull

The narrators voice (not Charles Enderlin but that of Renaud Bernard, a signatory of the embarrassing letter of support for Charles after his loss in court) tells us:

“To show the violence of the combat, Arab televisions and Internet broadcast these images, photographed by a telephone. It would be a question [il s’agirait] of a missile strike on the first of January. The military [in the footage] wear the Hamas armband. In the crowd there are military, but also many civilian corpses.

Analysis

This sequence of events is immensely revealing about the dynamics, the driving forces that keep up Pallywood inertia, long after they’ve been brought to light. In a sense, this is the “Adnan al Haj” incident of the war, the poster-child for how the war has been waged in the media theater, and prima facie evidence of the perduring MSM attraction to Pallywood footage.

First, note that the original incident is actually a terrifying example of the contempt for human life that the people in Hamas — and many other Palestinian leaders — have for the lives of their civilians. To parade with live ammunition so badly maintained that it explodes in front of gawking youth at a demonstration, renders our legal term “criminal negligence” impoverished. This is a terribly and terribly revealing insight into the mentality of people enlisted in a death cult.

Of course, as with the Gaza Beach tragedy a year later, Hamas tried to blame Israel for their work — the classic scapegoating instinct that informs so much of Pallywood. At the time, given the presence of an opposing Palestinian voice (political rival Fatah), their efforts failed. But since the MSM showed no interest in the affair once it violated their framing narratives, what might have offered Western audiences an important insight into the dynamics of Palestinian political culture, failed to make much of an impact in the MSM.

But it stayed in the toxic blogosphere and reappeared as a Hamas originally wanted to use it — an accusation against Israel for precisely the brutality that Hamas directs, not at Israeli civilians, but at their own! It would be harder to find a more morally corrupt act of disinformation than this, even though such deeds abound in cyberspace.

Second, note how rapidly France2 was forced to retract, from the action of the blogosphere. This is, in a sense, the equivalent victory for the French empirically-critical blogosphere, whose gestation period benefited from the revelations of the Al Durah case, and which had already made itself felt when France2 circulated their stunningly ignorant petition for Charles Enderlin. The many comments on the Figaro article about it are overwhelmingly critical of France2 and fully aware of the links between this and the Al Durah affair. As one punned, “Pourvu… que sa Dura. [”As long as/would that it last/s.”]

The apology of Etienne Leenhardt, Adjunct Director of Information at France2, is revealing:

It is an error on our part to have broadcast these images, which in fact, date from 2005. The sequence that we broadcast was supposed to ilustrate the war of images on the Internet. The people who prepared the subject went too fast. It’s a good warning inoculation for our production unit. It reminds us to be very attentive on verifying our sources. We will present our excuses to our viewers tomorrow [Tuesday], during the JT of 1 PM.

Arlette Chabot, key player in the Al Durah trial, added her dismissive apologies — “In any case it’s not a manipulation, and the diffusion of the images only lasted 10 seconds…”

Note that the France2 team in Paris had every opportunity to check the viability of this video on the internet before running with it. A half a minute would have revealed the real story to any minimally competent fact checker. But it’s actually worse: France2 is the poster child for Western media dupe to Pallywood. They were forced to show (and felt compelled to censure!) their footage before a packed courtroom, and when they tried to defend themselves with their own video, they made more mistakes.

 

 

Part of what makes this video so shocking to people who know this material, is how sloppy this is. And it doesn’t stop at one piece of footage. It’s a whole mentality, fed by a systematic lack of familiarity with the issues at play.

 

 

Apparently the whole fiasco wasn’t warning enough. France2 and Enderlin tried to maintain their dignity even as it maintained a flatlined learning curve.

And what about the documentary that came to their defense that warned against toxic content on the internet? Surely they knew about that.

So, une petite piqure, a little shot innoculating them from missteps is actually pretty weak language. France2 actually participated in the very viral war of images — on the side of the haters, on the side of those who are destabilizing Arab governments throughout the Middle East, and tearing up the streets of Paris and London.

This is hardly a “petite bavure,” a little slip. On the contrary, this incident deserves closer attention and denunciation. Fortunately, call for serious censure has come from a number of anti-raciste organizations in France, including LICRA the one whose director is supposed to do the investigation into the Al Durah case. France2 cannot be happy.

Note the careful circumlocutions and the framing of the presentation: the narrator makes it clear this is not France2 footage, that it may be suspicious (although that word is never uttered). He may well know that this is unrealiable but wants to use it anyway.

And the reason for that, is that this footage fits into his narrative seamlessly: “Israelis slaughter Palestinian civilians mercilessly.” The preceding scene covered a strike that Palestinian sources claim came from an Israeli naval vessel firing off the coast. Then, to drive home the point, he runs with the toxic footage.

The narrative is clear: Everything we ever read about how Western imperialists engaged in rampant, genocidal slaughter of native populations… is true again, of the Israelis. Think a scene from The Last Samurai, where he feverishly remembers the slaughter of Indian civilians… that’s the Israelis.

(The bitter irony of it all, is that the Arabs are unquestionably frustrated genocides, who openly declare their intentions to anyone who cares to listen.)

What this incident reveals most strikingly is what one might call the irresistible appeal that MSM reporters — especially Europeans like the folks at France2 — have for footage and stories that make Israel look bad, or even worse, like the most ruthless murderers around. Little truffles of moral Schadenfreude that make Europeans feel so superior to the Israelis, a sense that permeates the challenges posed to them by TV anchors with limited understanding of the conflict. With such bait within reach, our journalist could not resist snapping at it.

The wretched irony here is that had Stephane Malleterre and his Canal+ crew, who did an investigative report on the toxic elements on the web, rather than putting Philippe Karsenty and me in the same bag with Holocaust Deniers and 9-11 Truthers as “conspiracy nuts,” but showed how France2 had fed a worldwide hatred by being duped by Talal abu Rahmeh, then perhaps this might have been avoided. Had Canal+ held its colleagues at France2 up for criticism as dupes of this conspiratorial toxic web culture, rather than smeared us, who know? Maybe France2 would have already gotten their “inoculation”?

And so, the cost of spreading the toxic environment that fuels the street demonstrations, that rally useful fools like Annie Lennox, France2 feeds the fatal addiction of Europeans for anything that gives them a sense of moral superiority to the Israelis. Alas, what a tragedy for everyone, Palestinians included.

 

pouring gas on jihad ansm

 

Comments (0)Add Comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 

Banner_VIE_small2

/

Banner_SEE_small2

 

 

animated_banner

Facebook MySpace Twitter Digg Google Bookmarks